Breaking Dave the pine tree promoted to Chief Strategy Officer · One dress shoe worn to ceremony ·  ❖  Terrence responds to Phyllis's dinner notice: "Let's circle back on that" ·  ❖  Patricia the refrigerator still making new sound · Clifford not surprised ·  ❖  Gary (the dog) attends second walk · Described as "fully present" ·  ❖  The Pothos declines comment · Consistent with known philosophy ·  ❖  Dave the pine tree promoted to Chief Strategy Officer · One dress shoe worn to ceremony ·  ❖  Terrence responds to Phyllis's dinner notice: "Let's circle back on that" ·  ❖  Patricia the refrigerator still making new sound · Clifford not surprised ·  ❖  Gary (the dog) attends second walk · Described as "fully present" ·  ❖  The Pothos declines comment · Consistent with known philosophy ·  ❖ 
Monday, June 8, 2026  ·  Vol. CXLIV No. 212 For Better or For Worse, Preferably Better. Est. 1882  ·  Print Edition $1.00

My Husband Is "In a Meeting" Every Day From 2 to 4 PM — The Meeting Is With a Pine Tree Named Dave

Our panel diagnoses Post-Retirement Phantom Productivity Syndrome, explains the significance of the one dress shoe, and addresses whether a pine tree can be a co-respondent in a marriage.

Panel Verdict
Phyllis Is Fine. Terrence Is Not. Dave Is Unclear.
7,214 readers found this helpful
Panel Response (1)
🎓
RelationshipRealist_Constance, Ph.D., LMFT
Verified Respondent · Post-Retirement Behavioral Studies
Do Not Knock

Phyllis, take a breath. You are not losing your grip on reality. Terrence is.

What you are describing is a textbook case of Post-Retirement Phantom Productivity Syndrome (PRPPS), in which a formerly employed individual manufactures professional obligations in order to preserve a sense of purpose and structure. Dave is almost certainly functioning as a stand-in client, and the one dress shoe is a well-observed coping mechanism that experts refer to as "half-committing." It is more common than you think. I personally have three such cases on my roster right now, and one of them has promoted the tree to Senior Vice President.

The Post-It "circle back" response is actually an encouraging sign. Terrence is still communicating. He is still in the relationship. He is simply conducting it via interoffice memo.

My recommendations: First, do not knock. You would not interrupt a board meeting; please extend the same courtesy to Dave. Second, consider submitting an official meeting request — a handwritten calendar invite slipped under the back door has shown strong results in similar cases. Third, if you need to reach Terrence urgently, the words "Q3 review" have been shown to cut through even the deepest arboreal focus.

You ask whether your marriage is now a three-party situation. Legally, no. Emotionally? Phyllis, I think you already know. Dave was always in this marriage. You just didn't have his name until now.

Reader Commentary (4,102)

Sort by: Top · New · Controversial
🌲
NormaFromAlbuquerque Top Commenter Jun 8, 2026
I read "circle back" and had to put my phone down and walk around my apartment.
▲ 1▽ 4Reply
🙏
Anonymous Jun 8, 2026
My prayers are with Dave.
▲ 3▽ 4Reply
👞
OneShoeObserver Jun 8, 2026
The one dress shoe is the detail I cannot get past. Not both shoes. One. He is half-committed to this meeting, Phyllis. There is a part of him that knows.
▲ 7▽ 0Reply
📋
RetiredAccountant_Howard Jun 8, 2026
I am also a retired accountant and I want to say: we are fine. Most of us are fine. But I did name my maple "Gerald" last spring so perhaps do not quote me on this.
▲ 8▽ 4Reply